Global: Planning and managing a global reduction in force: Ten considerations for employers
At a glance
- Amid geopolitical and economic uncertainty, as well as the acceleration of artificial intelligence (AI), employers are considering and implementing reductions in force (RIFs).
- However, before proceeding, employers are encouraged to plan in advance. Failure to comply with applicable legal requirements may result in various risks, including fines, employee reinstatement, and criminal penalties.
- To help employers identify and address these risks, we set out ten key considerations for planning and implementing a global RIF below, along with current trends.
1. Obtain key information and consider forming a working group
In order to identify legal obligations and evaluate risks, gather key information early in the process. During the planning stage, employers are encouraged to determine the total headcount of affected employees per jurisdiction and document the following information where relevant:
- State or province where employees are located.
- Collective employee groups and collective bargaining agreements in place.
- Types of employees (eg fixed-term, probationary, or contingent workers).
- Prior RIF policies and practices.
In preparation for a potential RIF, employers may also wish to form a working group early to define each member’s role. For example, it may be helpful to establish at the outset the chain of command, decision-making authority (including for severance pay and selection decisions), and responsibility for leading meetings with employees. This type of project management has become increasingly important in implementing RIFs.
Employers may also consider establishing focused working groups to help preserve legal privilege. In some countries, such as the United Kingdom, disseminating legal advice beyond a defined core group can risk the loss of legal privilege. Accordingly, employers are encouraged to exercise care when sharing legal advice.
Depending on the composition of the working group, employers may also wish to ask members to sign nondisclosure agreements to help maintain confidentiality.
2. Determine economic justification
While most jurisdictions recognize redundancies, local standards for justifying such terminations differ. In many jurisdictions, employers implementing a RIF carry the burden of proving that the exits were economically justified.
In some countries, such as the United States and Australia, limited evidence of a business decline is typically sufficient. In others, including Japan and much of mainland Europe, the justification may be held to a more stringent legal standard, requiring employers to demonstrate a significant and sustained business decline to justify layoffs.
The ultimate business rationale may be closely scrutinized by government authorities or unions and works councils, which may substantially delay the RIF. Employers are encouraged to prepare and document the business rationale in countries where required and avoid inconsistent communications with employees before the RIF is implemented. Certain messaging, such as overly positive accounts of the business, may be cited against them by employees and other stakeholders.
3. Consider alternative options
As part of determining the business justification, employers are encouraged to consider whether viable alternatives to a RIF are available. Doing so may help bolster the business case if a RIF becomes the only viable option.
Other cost-saving measures, including reducing hours and pay, introducing flexible roles, or ending engagements with non-company employees, may help avoid permanent downsizing. In some countries, the employer may have an obligation to consider workforce alternatives that would avoid layoffs, such as ending engagements with independent contractors, as Australia’s High Court ruled last year.
Employers may also wish to consider alternative reorganization schemes, such as voluntary separation programs (VSPs), which offer a group of employees a separation package that they may accept or decline.
Notably, while VSPs are generally permissible, some countries impose specific requirements on how the VSP must be structured or communicated to employees. For example, in certain jurisdictions, a VSP could trigger both mass layoff laws and notice and consultation requirements under which, notwithstanding the voluntary nature of the exit, employee participation would be deemed a layoff.
Because employers cannot ultimately control the number of participants who accept the terms of the VSP, they may not be able to avoid triggering those requirements. The selection of employees asked to participate in the VSP could also result in discrimination claims.
For this reason, employers may consider offering separation packages to all employees in a jurisdiction while retaining the right to exclude certain employees from participation if the number of volunteers exceeds the employer’s needs. However, by its nature, this approach may significantly affect the employee selection process and should be considered in light of the associated risks.
4. Consider the employee selection process
When proceeding with a RIF, legal considerations may, depending on the jurisdiction and surrounding circumstances, significantly limit or determine which employees may be selected.
Some countries impose specific statutory criteria governing the process by which employees must be selected, such as the 'last-in, first-out' approach which is required in several countries, for example, Sweden. Additionally, in many countries, terminating certain employees with protected statuses is prohibited or requires special procedures, such as governmental approval, even in the context of a RIF.
Generally, employers are encouraged to consult local law before seeking to terminate any employee who is on sick leave or parental leave, serves as an employee representative, or has sustained an occupational injury.
Where specific selection criteria are not outlined by law, employers are still encouraged to develop fair, objective, and consistent criteria that reflect legitimate business needs to inform the employee selection process. Failure to apply appropriate selection criteria may result in claims. It can also be helpful for employers to be aware of recent trends in this area, including those related to AI, as discussed further below.
5. Evaluate notice and consultation obligations
Employers are encouraged to identify any legal obligations to provide advance notice to individual employees, their representatives (eg works councils), or governmental authorities, or to participate in a consultation process with such parties.
The specific requirements vary significantly depending on jurisdiction and other circumstances; in some cases, this process may take several months to complete. In practice, particularly in the UK and mainland Europe, notice and consultation obligations may significantly affect the timeline for implementing a global RIF. Thus, identifying and accounting for notice and consultation obligations can help facilitate a smooth and cost-effective RIF.
Further, statutory consultation requirements may be triggered before any layoff has occurred, depending on how proposals are communicated. To avoid premature announcements that could have such unintended consequences at this stage, employers may wish to note all plans as being provisional and subject to local legal requirements.
In particular, where local law requires a consultation process, employers are encouraged to refer to terminations of employment as preliminary in nature until the consultation process is complete, even internally. Especially in the UK and mainland Europe, the process cannot appear to be a fait accompli in which the consultation is treated as a mere formality after the termination decision has already been made.
Accordingly, employers may wish to mark all communications concerning contemplated termination of employment as preliminary.
6. Assess mass layoff laws
If the redundancy affects multiple employees, employers are encouraged to identify the mass layoff headcount threshold for the relevant jurisdiction and assess which obligations are triggered.
Many jurisdictions, including the US, have laws triggered by group layoffs (or 'collective redundancies', as they are commonly called outside of the US). The specific thresholds at which such laws are triggered vary by jurisdiction.
For example, the US federal mass layoff law applies when a covered employer implements a 'plant closing' or 'mass layoff', defined by statute to include, among other criteria, employment losses impacting 50 or more employees at a single site of employment. By contrast, as few as five impacted employees can trigger analogous laws in countries such as Ireland and Italy for certain employers.
Where mass layoff laws are triggered, employers may be required to make public filings or obtain governmental consent. Noncompliance can result in severe penalties in certain countries, including criminal sanctions in the UK and Ireland.
7. Navigate unions, works councils, and employee representatives
Employers may wish to plan for additional considerations when a portion of the impacted workforce is represented by a union, works council, or other employee representatives.
The presence of these representatives may affect RIF implementation in various ways, including by requiring the employer to undergo a notice and consultation process, as noted above; dictating how the employer must select participants in the RIF; or determining what payouts may be due at termination.
Labor organizing has increasingly expanded into new industries, particularly the technology sector. Waves of layoffs and rising concerns over AI may be among the issues accelerating this trend. The UK has also recently passed legislation increasing union access to the workplace to be aware of.
Employers may face increased pressure when planning RIFs at a time of increased interest in collective bargaining, underscoring the importance of careful planning and implementation.
8. Calculate the true cost of the RIF
Outside the US, employees are generally entitled to prior notice (and thereby salary and benefits continuation through the notice period) or possibly pay in lieu of notice. Employees may also be entitled to severance, either under local law, through their employment contract, or under a collective bargaining agreement. Further, where an employer has a history of awarding enhanced severance – payments exceeding required minimums – there may be an implied legal obligation to continue this practice under local law.
Additional payment obligations can also arise and may include noncompete payouts, earned but unused vacation time, commissions and bonuses, or buyouts triggered by past equity awards. Some countries, especially in mainland Europe, further require employers to develop and implement so-called 'social plans', which may consist of severance pay, training programs, outplacement services, or similar measures benefiting impacted employees.
Another consideration arises where an employer contracts with employers of record (EORs) or professional employer organizations (PEOs); exiting impacted employees may trigger early termination fees or other requirements under the parties’ services agreement.
The use of EORs or PEOs to engage workers may present additional considerations in a RIF. EOR / PEO employees participating in a RIF generally must be terminated by the EOR / PEO. This can create additional risks, particularly in countries that do not recognize the EOR / PEO model.
If such dismissals trigger mass layoff laws, the risk of noncompliance with locally prescribed processes may fall on both the EOR / PEO and its end-user client, particularly where the client indemnifies the EOR / PEO under the terms of the parties’ services agreement.
The EOR / PEO may also require additional time to implement terminations. To mitigate risks such as joint employment and misclassification, the end-user client may wish to avoid involvement in the termination process, including employee selection, and therefore may have little ability to influence it and the costs incurred.
Finally, though generally not required, employers may wish to offer enhanced separation packages in exchange for a general release of claims. Such packages may range considerably, from a few weeks’ compensation to several months or a year or more. Obtaining releases from impacted employees often mitigates certain risks associated with a global RIF.
9. Consider developments in AI laws
Developments in AI-related laws may also be relevant when planning RIFs. Several US states, including California, Connecticut, and New York, either require or will soon require employers to include AI-related disclosures as part of applicable mass layoff reporting requirements.
In California, for example, these additional disclosures will include information about layoffs substantially due to AI or other automation, including the number, occupations, and work locations of affected employees; the job functions to be automated; and the technology that led to the layoffs.
The evolving landscape of AI-related regulation is not limited to mass layoff laws. Employers may also consider potential implications when using automated tools that might determine or impact employee selection. In particular, notice and consultation requirements may be triggered outside of the US where AI tools are used to select RIF participants.
In Germany, for example, using an AI tool during the employee selection process may trigger works council co-determination rights depending on the nature of the AI tool. In Spain, new regulations have been rolled out this year under which, in addition to existing obligations vis-à-vis works councils and employee representatives, individual employees are generally entitled to be informed of any parameters, rules, or instructions that form the basis for algorithms or AI tools that make decisions impacting working conditions.
As a practical matter, outside of the US, employers planning to substitute AI for existing workers may also have to disclose that fact in termination letters as the business reason for the exit and may face legal challenges on that basis.
In the US, several states have also passed laws specifically regulating the use of AI technology in employment-related decisions, including termination. Two employer-specific examples are:
- California’s SB 947, which takes effect on July 1, 2027, prohibits employers from relying solely on a so-called 'automated decision system' or 'ADS' when making disciplinary or termination decisions. Further, an employer who 'primarily relies' on this technology to make a disciplinary or termination decision must undergo a specific process consisting of human corroboration and written notice to impacted employees.
- Connecticut’s Public Act 26-15 generally will require that employers give prior written notice to impacted employees when they use AI for the purpose of making, or as 'a substantial factor in making', an employment-related decision on or after October 1, 2027.
10. Prepare and roll out exit paperwork
Generally, an individual dismissal in a global RIF is effected through delivery of a termination notice, often accompanied by a release of claims in exchange for an ex gratia payment, although a release is not required.
Because local laws tend to impose different and potentially contradictory rules with respect to requirements for termination notices or releases of claims, employers are encouraged to implement country-specific documents developed with local legal counsel. Employers may also wish to consider applicable local law to account for potential differences in areas such as the timing of employee communications, translation requirements, and cultural factors.
Some jurisdictions also have specific rules on the delivery and signatory requirements for such dismissal paperwork to be effective. For example, in Germany, delivery of an original wet-ink-signed dismissal letter is mandatory for an effective dismissal. Further, in the UK, settlement agreements will only effectively waive statutory claims if the impacted employee has obtained advice from an independent legal adviser. Awareness of such procedural steps may therefore help to ensure that exit documents are enforceable at this final phase.
While employers have a variety of tools at their disposal to balance personnel needs against an evolving macroeconomic landscape, careful planning can help ensure that workplace strategies ultimately serve business demands.
Even with time-sensitive RIFs, employers are encouraged to consider the ten considerations above before moving forward to avoid common pitfalls, identify and plan for risk, and smoothly execute complex workforce strategies.
DLA Piper's Employment and AI and Data Analytics teams continue to monitor these developments. For more information, please contact the authors or your DLA Piper relationship partner.