Federal Appeals Court permits enforcement of DEI Executive Orders

21 March 2025 4 min read

By Holly R. Lake, Ryan Estes, Lolan Ekow Sagoe-Moses and Robert Yap

At a glance

  • The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals stayed the Maryland District Court’s preliminary injunction, allowing enforcement of President Trump’s DEI Executive Orders.
  • The stay permits the government to terminate equity-related grants or contracts and require federal contractors to certify they do not operate 'illegal DEI' programs.
  • The appellate ruling was unanimous, with judges agreeing the government showed a likelihood of success on the merits.
  • Judge Harris noted the EOs are limited in scope and do not establish the illegality of all DEI efforts, but enforcement actions beyond the Orders’ scope could raise constitutional concerns.
  • The Fourth Circuit will expedite the briefing schedule for the government’s appeal.

The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has stayed the Maryland District Court’s preliminary injunction order enjoining the federal government from enforcing certain provisions of President Donald Trump’s January 20, 2025 Executive Orders 14151, 'Ending Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs and Preferencing,' and 14173, 'Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity' (collectively, EOs).

The appellate ruling, made on March 15, 2025, clears the way for enforcement of the DEI EOs, which is already under way, with multiple agencies announcing investigations into private employers for discrimination in their diversity policies, practices, and programs. See our alert, Enforcement of President Trump’s DEI Executive Order: A strategic roadmap for companies targeted for investigation and enforcement.

The Fourth Circuit stays the District Court’s preliminary injunction

As we shared in our prior alert, the National Association of Diversity Officers in Higher Education and other plaintiffs commenced the first known lawsuit challenging the DEI EOs against President Trump and certain departments and agencies. The Maryland District Court found that the plaintiffs had shown a likelihood of success on the merits of their claims that the EOs are unconstitutionally vague and violate First Amendment free speech rights, and issued an injunction prohibiting the government (excluding the President) from:

  • pausing, modifying, impeding, or terminating any federal awards, contracts, and obligations;
  • requiring federal contractors or grantees to certify that they do not operate any 'illegal DEI'; and
  • bringing any enforcement action, including under the False Claims Act.

The Fourth Circuit, in a unanimous opinion by a panel comprised of Chief Judge Albert Diaz, Judge Pamela Harris, and Judge Allison Jones Rushing, granted the government’s motion for a stay of the preliminary injunction until the government’s appeal is decided. All three judges concurred that the government satisfied its burden to show a likelihood of success on the merits.

In her concurring opinion, which was joined by Chief Judge Diaz, Judge Harris reasoned that the injunction should be stayed because:

  • The EOs "are of distinctly limited scope".
  • The EOs "do not purport to establish the illegality of all efforts to advance diversity, equity, or inclusion".
  • The certification and enforcement provisions of EO 14173 "apply only to conduct that violates existing federal anti-discrimination law".
  • The EOs do not "authorize the termination of grants based on a grantee’s speech or activities outside the scope of the funded activities."

While Judge Harris appeared to express that the EOs are likely constitutional, she left open the possibility for challenges to how they are enforced, stating: What the Orders say on their face and how they are enforced are two different things. Agency enforcement actions that go beyond the Orders’ narrow scope may well raise serious First Amendment and Due Process concerns.

Judge Harris made it clear that her “vote should not be understood as agreement with the EOs’ attack on efforts to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion.” Although she and Chief Judge Diaz concurred that the injunction should be stayed, they both expressed views favoring DEI principles. Chief Judge Diaz wrote that “people of good faith who work to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion deserve praise, not opprobrium.” He further noted that, under “the First Amendment, there should be room for open discussion and principled debate about DEI programs,” and that “all Americans should be able to freely consider how to continue empowering historically disadvantaged groups.”

Judge Rushing, in her concurring opinion, noted:

  • The plaintiffs’ “case does not challenge any particular agency action implementing the Executive Orders,” which “highlights serious questions about the ripeness of the lawsuit and plaintiffs’ standing to bring it as an initial matter.”
  • “Any individual judge’s view on whether certain Executive action is good policy” is “irrelevant to fulfilling the courts’ duty to adjudicate cases and controversies according to the law” and that a “judge’s opinion that DEI programs ‘deserve praise, not opprobrium’ should play absolutely no part in deciding the case.’”

The Fourth Circuit indicated it would set an expedited briefing schedule on the government’s appeal.

Key takeaways

Since the injunction has been paused, the government can use the EOs to:

  • Terminate equity-related grants or contracts, as well as all DEI performance requirements for government employees, federal contractors, or recipients of federal grants.
  • Require federal contractors and grantees to certify that they do not operate any 'illegal DEI' that violates federal antidiscrimination laws.
  • Pursue enforcement actions, including bringing False Claims Act claims against companies in violation of the EO.
  • Investigate companies for 'illegal DEI' policies and practices. Investigations were not enjoined by the Maryland District Court’s injunction order.

We will continue to monitor developments. In the meantime, for more information about the DEI EOs and their implications, please contact any of the authors or your DLA Piper relationship attorney and ask about our toolkit, Assessing risk under President Trump’s DEI Executive Order: A strategic roadmap for private employers and federal contractors.

For more information on President Trump’s EOs and other federal developments, see our President Trump Executive Orders topic hub.

More to explore

US federal: Equal Employment Opportunity Commission rescinds enforcement guidance on use of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions

US federal: Equal Employment Opportunity Commission rescinds enforcement guidance on use of arrest and conviction records in employment decisions

Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 is withdrawn, but risks remain.

US federal: Diversity, equity, and inclusion practices face increased scrutiny

US federal: Diversity, equity, and inclusion practices face increased scrutiny

US agencies are increasing scrutiny of DEI programmes while proposing to scale back diversity data reporting requirements.

Equality and Human Rights Commission updates its guidance as new harassment protections in the workplace take effect in UK

Equality and Human Rights Commission updates its guidance as new harassment protections in the workplace take effect in UK

EHRC updates its guidance as new UK workplace protections against harassment take effect.

Laicity in Quebec: Greater flexibility for private-sector employers regarding religious accommodations

Laicity in Quebec: Greater flexibility for private-sector employers regarding religious accommodations

Quebec has lowered the threshold for refusing religious accommodation requests, giving private-sector employers greater flexibility.

Draft Labour Law to require seats for women workers

Draft Labour Law to require seats for women workers

Bahrain may require employers to provide seats for women workers under a proposed amendment to the Labour Law.

France has disclosed a draft bill to implement the Gender Pay Transparency Directive (update)

France has disclosed a draft bill to implement the Gender Pay Transparency Directive (update)

France has disclosed a draft bill proposing new pay transparency, gender pay reporting and enforcement obligations for employers.

Questions? Launch AI Assist